Trinity 4, oneness pentecostals, the holy spirit, and the trinity defend 2017. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity international society. Oneness pentecostals believe that trinitarian doctrine is a tradition of men and neither scriptural nor a teaching of god, and cite the absence of the word trinity from the bible as one evidence of this. If god is unitarian, then islam, jehovahs witnesses, christadelphians, and other unitarian groups are right and christianity is wrong. Unlike mormons and jehovahs witnesses, for example, oneness pentecostals teach both that there is one god and that jesus is fully god. A multifaceted movement that denies the doctrine of the trinity and requires repentance, baptism by water, and baptism by the holy spirit as essential requirements for salvation. Oneness believers and trinitarians have the same scriptures available to them. In this penetrating analysis of oneness theology and practice, gregory boyd writes from the experience of his four years of personal involvement in a oneness church. But the trinity is not about 3 gods and the teaching of the trinity was clearly present well before the existence of the catholic church.
Oneness pentecostals jesus only understanding oneness pentecostalism oneness pentecostals reject the trinity. Oneness pentecostalism also known as apostolic or jesus name pentecostalism is a movement within the christian family of churches known as pentecostalism. Indeed, paul tells us that he rarely baptized people at all, since this was not his calling 1 cor. In this first section, i want to present there doctrine to you without criticism. The oneness doctrine of oneness pentecostals is not revelation from god. Of course, there are obvious examples of this, like the mormons and the jehovahs witnesses. Christian denomination or dangerous cult by edingess published february 4, 2018 given the recent controversy involving the question of the trinity in oneness pentecostalism and whether or not someone can reject the orthodox doctrine of the trinity and be in true fellowship with god, i think it is a good idea to raise. Hope you have a chance to deal with my 7part post to you.
Oneness pentecostalism and their false doctrine of. We believe in one god, the father almighty, creator of all things both visible and invisible. But if, as the oneness pentecostals claim, jesus is the father. Pdf trinity 4, oneness pentecostals, the holy spirit, and the trinity. Oneness pentecostalism sometimes called the jesus only movement is different from orthodox pentecostalism. The jesus only or oneness pentecostal doctrine of god examined. The author has made blatant false accusations of oneness pentecostals. This belief has been referred to as oneness or jesus only. What are the beliefs of jesus only oneness pentecostals. Gregs story behind the writing of oneness pentecostals and the trinity. With roger perkins, matt slicks opening statement on trinity. Early hebrew matthew texts did not contain any triune phrases in matthew 28. In his book oneness pentecostals and the trinity hereafter opt, gregory boyd, assistant professor of theology at bethel college, clearly explains and effectively refutes a modernday version of an ancient heresy. Oneness pentecostalism and the trinity bible info brokers.
In the near 25 years since the publication of gregory boyds oneness pentecostals and the trinity there has been a dearth of critical interaction with the arguments and exegetical underpinnings of oneness pentecostal theology. Oneness theology specifically maintains that god is absolutely and indivisibly one. Trinity issue is not simply an issue of what the scripture teaches. We were taught that no one other than oneness pentecostals were saved. The oneness trinitarian pentecostal final report dialogue. Followers of this blog will know that i have spent a lot of time writing about oneness pentecostalism, because, as i pointed out in my article my conversion from oneness pentecostalism to biblical christianity, i used to be a oneness pentecostal and i think that this issue is very. Oneness pentecostalism, the holy spirit, and the trinity. Gregory boyd, oneness pentecostals and the trinity, and the second.
Have a clear understanding of your faith and the bible. United pentecostal church international our doctrinal foundation new testament salvation 1. In addition to their view of the godhead, oneness pentecostals have many reasons to be labeled a cult. Im a former oneness pentecostal, ask me questions about. Many people do not know who oneness pentecostals are or what they believe. Oneness pentecostal theology affirms that there exists only one god in all the universe. One who believes the gospel according to oneness pentecostalism has no choice but to see themselves as more right, more holy, and more spiritual than everyone else. Modalism made its first appearance in the third century a. For this reason we tenaciously teach our children on the dangerous errors of this antibiblical doctrine in accordance with deuteronomy 6.
Oneness pentecostals are unique as far as being considered a cult. This study examines the explosive growth of one fringe group of the pentecostal movement. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity and trinity and. His most recent contribution, in jesus name, goes into detail on oneness history and theology, but he primarily focuses his latter efforts on the significance of the name of jesus. Setting the record straight geographical and temporal markers in the canonical gospels. I can back all of this even with catholic writings and the bible itself. My conversion from oneness pentecostalism to biblical. Boyd argues that although oneness pentecostals belief in christs deity establishes some common ground with other christians, their aggressive denial of the trinity has nonetheless fostered their. A history of oneness throughout the centuries free download as pdf file. While the words trinity and oneness are not found in the bible, this truth doesnt mean anything in determining the veracity, or lack thereof, of either teaching. Oneness pentecostalism profile watchman fellowship. Oneness pentecostalism and the trinity by robert m. What is it and how is it different from the trinity doctrine. Refuting its soteriology, christology, and theology by e.
Oneness pentecostalism also known as jesus name or apostolic pentecostalism refers to a grouping of organizations and believers within pentecostal christianity, all of whom subscribe to the theological doctrine of oneness. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity logos bible software. It derives its distinctive name from its teaching on the godhead, which is popularly referred to as the oneness doctrine, a form of modalistic monarchianism. I am having a bit of trouble understanding it completely. Oneness pentecostalism simple english wikipedia, the free.
For this reason, many christians have difficulty seeing anything wrong with the oneness position. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity greg boyd reknew. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity book by gregory a. This book also shows how oneness pentecostals have a basic misunderstanding of what the doctrine of the trinity really teaches. Boyd, oneness pentecostals and the trinity grand rapids.
Oneness pentecostals and the trinity quotes by gregory a. Christian members please remember to read the statement of purpose threads for each forum within christian congregations before posting in the forum. Oneness pentecostals by any criteria fit within the category of christianity broadly defined. An astonishing number of professing christians today reject the doctrine of the trinity. The jesus only movement, also known as oneness pentecostalism or oneness theology, teaches that there is only one god, but denies the triunity of god. What sets oneness pentecostalism apart from other antitrinitarian heresies is its seeming orthodoxy. Although oneness pentecostals belief in christs deity establishes some common ground with other christians, their aggressive denial of the trinity has nonetheless fostered their indisputably subchristian ideas about gods character, about salvation, and about christian living. A worldwide movement is assessed by a former oneness pentecostal who warns that the time has passed for ignoring this small group.
Although it has become much more common in recent years, its roots go back to an ancient jewish feast and, more recently, to the first outpouring of the holy spirit on the earliest christian believers. Is the oneness versus trinity debate theological nitpicking. I was wrong oneness pentecostalism and the trinity joel hemphill after some 50 years as a oneness pentecostal minister, joel hemphill came to the realization that he was wrong. What has gone very much unnoticed by the church and is also enjoying growth is the oneness pentecostal apostolic church movement. In other words, oneness theology does not recognize the distinct persons of the godhead. Oneness pentecostals believe that trinitarian doctrine is a tradition of men. Oneness pentecostalism have discounted, distorted or dismissed the threein one doctrine of the. And in one lord jesus christ, the son of god, the only. Lately i have read a bit about the pentecostal oneness doctrine. Then there are the christian liberals who reject the trinity along with the incarnation as myths. One of the two most distinguishing beliefs and practices within oneness pentecostalism along with jesus only baptism see below is modalism. I have been accused of losing my revelation by leaving the oneness doctrine and accepting the doctrine of the trinity. Jakes embraces doctrine of the trinity, moves away fr.
It must be written interestingly and must fill a need. Chalfant examines the extant writings of the earliest bishops of rome, showing that at least the first 17 were modalists. Answers and responses to questions to ask oneness believers. What are the main doctrines of the upci that are unbiblical. Ive studied their doctrines for almost thirty years now. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity 9780801010194 by gregory a. Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. His lack of clear organization, both in text and documentation of source materials, makes for inconvenient, tedious reading.
Trinity debate david bernard and gene cook duration. People who make such an accusation are people who are ignorant of scripture. Oneness pentecostals are a cult group which denies historic and biblical christianity as we shall see. Oneness pentecostal churches are, therefore, cultic in nature and outside the theological parameters of historic christianity. Oneness pentecostalism have discounted, distorted or dismissed the threeinone doctrine of the. Nick norelli rightly dividing the word of truth new jersey nearly twenty years ago a brighteyed, bushytailed greg boyd wrote a book defending the doctrine of the trinity against the objections of oneness pentecostals. Im a former oneness pentecostal, also known as apostolics or jesus only. Oneness pentecostals assert that the idea that god is both three and one is obviously incoherent. A second book by the author addressing oneness beliefs, released in july 2016. If it was simply a matter of an awareness of certain bible verses, then everyone who has read the bible in its entirety should have the same understanding of the nature of god. Dec 26, 20 john macarthur on pentecostal oneness heresies about the trinity panteleaz. Would anyone like to ask me some questions about them.
Apostolic academics oneness pentecostal apologetics page 2. Ecumenical documents and critical assessments eugene, or. Apr 02, 2014 oneness teachers would agree that salvation requires putting ones full faith in the jesus of oneness doctrine that is the jesus who is the totality of the godhead, who died on the cross as atonement for sin, and who rose again from the dead. Aug 16, 2016 is the oneness versus trinity debate theological nitpicking. I was wrong oneness pentecostalism and the trinity.
Pdf analysis of oneness pentecostalism fred sanders. Which now is the third largest antitrinitarian church in the world, having anywhere from 56 million or more adherents. The united pentecostal church teaches that god is one, manifesting himself in three ways. Acquire a basic knowledge of oneness pentecostals beliefs and practices. Oneness pentecostalism is a movement within the christian family of churches known as. The oneness questions and answers are in purple and enclosed in single greater than and lesser than signs. The trinity is a christian doctrine of the union of the father, son, and the holy spirit in a single godhead. Oneness pentecostals outright reject the triune nature of god and instead take a unitarian position, namely that god is not only singular in being monotheism but. Providing scholarly discussions on biblical topics by oneness pentecostals. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity ebook 9781441214966 by gregory a. Much of what you gave me here is your theology of the godhead which i hope i understand better now. Boyd clarifies misconception that the early church believed a oneness gospel and carefully distinguishes the views of oneness believers from trinitarian pentecostals and charismatics. In 1974 i surrendered my life to jesus christ and had a powerful encounter with god. Oneness pentecostalism is a distinct sect within pentecostalism that is known for denying the doctrine of the trinity, denying justification by faith alone, and their belief that all true believers will speak in tongues.
Representative of the movement, a pastortheologian writes, baptism in the name of the lord jesus christ endures as the premiere issue for oneness pentecostalisma corollary doctrine with the oneness of god. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity grand rapids, mi. Jun 10, 2009 grady calls pentecostalism a house divided. In contrast, the majority of christian churches teach a trinitarian concept. The trinity and oneness doctrine come reason ministries. The trinity, the definition of chalcedon, and oneness theology web page by james white the man, his ministry, and his movement. Modalism, otherwise known as sabellianism or jesus only christology, teaches that jesus christ is the father, son, and holy spirit, and that the trinity is false. Oneness pentecostals reject the doctrine of the trinity as the word trinity is never found in the bible and believe the concept of describing god as a person limits god. That charge does absolutely nothing to harm trinitarian theology. I have no problem with baptism with the formula in the name of jesus christ. This site debates the question of oneness and the trinity. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity boyd, gregory a on.
The oneness pentecostal movement teaches that the biblical, apostolic, christian doctrine of god, which it commonly calls oneness, excludes the modem. I have profited from the previously published research on oneness pentecostalism, but it seems to me that much of the research is several years behind the current state of play for this rapidlydeveloping movement. This movement was birthed out of the assemblies of god in the early 20 th century. While the words trinity and oneness are not found in the bible, this truth doesnt mean anything in determining the veracity, or lack thereof, of. In this presentation, he gives a sincere and honest address to a conference of ministers from both oneness and trinititarian. The forums in the christian congregations category are now open only to christian members. Oneness pentecostalism is a descriptive name for an antitrinitarian religious. Oneness pentecostals believe that god is one spirit who manifests himself as he chooses including as the father, son, and holy spirit. Departure from the united pentecostal church and oneness. The oneness of god and baptism in jesus name are not joined at the hip the biblical teaching on judgmentalism. Dr boyd quotes extensively from accepted oneness doctrine and oneness writers, so i think its unfair to say that the oneness position is misrepresented. Jakes says he has moved away from a oneness view of the godhead to embrace an orthodox definition of the trinity and that some in the oneness pentecostal. It should be noted that many christian theologians have serious concerns regarding greg boyds theology the gospel according to oneness pentecostalism by former oneness pentecostalist mike barden. The oneness theology of the united pentecostal church.
Oneness pentecostals deny the trinity, believing instead that the monotheistic god simply manifests himself in the offices or roles of the members of the trinity. Oneness pentecostals are of the united pentecostal church international, and they have many unbiblical doctrines and teachings contrary to the christian faith. This makes them different from most unitarians who say that the son of god was only man. Modern oneness pentecostalism, also known as jesus only churches, with the upci united pentecostal church international being the largest oneness domination, is a development from early pentecostalism early 1900s emerging out of the assemblies of god church in 1914 which formed after the great outpouring of the holy spirit and. Oneness pentecostalist believe god is one which is a biblical view, but then deny the doctrine of the trinity by claiming that god. The jesus only oneness pentecostal doctrine of god. John macarthur on pentecostal oneness heresies about the trinity. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity quotes showing 15 of 5 paul preaches in a similar fashion acts 16. One of them, from what i have read, is the assembly of god denomination. Throughout this blogpost, i will relay my conversion from oneness pentecostalism to biblical christianity. The book also discusses how the oneness pentecostals have deviated from central biblical truths about god. A history of oneness throughout the centuries trinity scribd. I was involved with them in london, england in the last 1980s. Our intent is not to be judgmental but to be open to the truth and test all things in light of the scriptures.
Boyd argues that although oneness pentecostals belief in christs deity establishes some common ground with other christians, their aggressive denial of the trinity has nonetheless fostered their indisputably differing. This book has also strengthened my belief in the trinity. Search for library items search for lists search for contacts search for a library. Oneness pentecostals and the trinity ian kyle liberty theological. Oneness pentecostals are purveyors of a wicked plot six things there are, which the lord hateth, and the seventh his soul detesteth. With roger perkins, matt slicks opening statement on baptism. Pdf trinity 4, oneness pentecostals, the holy spirit. Did benny hinn really repent from teaching the prosperity gospel. In this penetrating analysis of oneness theology and practice, gregory boyd reveals the experience of four years of personal involvement in a oneness church. The trinity has been proven to be man made nonbiblicaldoctrines by the catholic church in ad325. Also i have heard that not all pentecostals are into the oneness doctrine, but teach the trinity. Oneness pentecostals and baptism in the name of jesus only thad, just wanted to let you know i received your two posts here. About oneness pentecostalism for many people, pentecostal is a new word.